A-1. Rules
of Disciplinary Procedure
An order of the Supreme Court
dated Feb. 26, 1991, as amended by an order of
the Supreme Court dated Oct. 9, 1991, adopted
the Texas Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, eff.
May 1, 1992.
Preamble
The Supreme Court of Texas has
the constitutional and statutory responsibility
within the State for the lawyer discipline and
disability system, and has inherent power to maintain
appropriate standards of professional conduct
and to dispose of individual cases of lawyer discipline
and disability in a manner that does not discriminate
by race, creed, color, sex, or national origin.
To carry out this responsibility, the Court promulgates
the following rules for lawyer discipline and
disability proceedings. Subject to the inherent
power of the Supreme Court of Texas, the responsibility
for administering and supervising lawyer discipline
and disability is delegated to the Board of Directors
of the State Bar of Texas. Authority to adopt
rules of procedure and administration not inconsistent
with these rules is vested in the Board. This
delegation is specifically limited to the rights,
powers, and authority herein expressly delegated.
Part I. General Rules
1.01. Citation
These rules are to be called the Texas Rules of
Disciplinary Procedure and shall be cited as such.
1.02. Objective of the Rules
These rules establish the procedures to be used
in the professional disciplinary and disability
system for attorneys in the State of Texas.
1.03. Construction of the Rules
These rules are to be broadly construed to ensure
the operation, effectiveness, integrity, and continuation
of the professional disciplinary and disability
system. The following rules apply in the construction
of these rules:
A. If any portion of these rules is held unconstitutional
by any court, that determination does not affect
the validity of the remaining rules.
B. The use of the singular includes the plural,
and vice versa.
C. In computing any period of time prescribed
or allowed by these rules, the day of the act
or event after which the designated period of
time begins to run is not to be included. The
last day of the period so computed is to be included,
unless it is a Saturday, Sunday, or legal holiday,
in which event the period runs until the end of
the next day that is not a Saturday, Sunday, or
legal holiday.
1.04. Integration and Concurrent Application of
the Rules
These rules apply prospectively to all attorney
professional disciplinary and disability proceedings
commenced on and after the effective date as set
forth in the Supreme Court’s Order of promulgation.
Upon adoption and promulgation of these rules,
existing Article X, Sections 1 through 8, and
Article X, Sections 10 through 38, of the State
Bar Rules (Title 2, Subtitle G—Appendix,
V.T.C.A., Government Code) are repealed except
to the extent that they apply to then pending
disciplinary matters by Order of the Supreme Court
of Texas.
1.05. Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional
Conduct
Nothing in these rules is to be construed, explicitly
or implicitly, to amend or repeal in any way the
Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct.
1.06 Definitions
A. “Board” means the Board of Directors
of the State Bar of Texas.
B. “Chief Disciplinary Counsel” means
the person serving as Chief Disciplinary Counsel
and any and all of his or her assistants.
C. “Commission” means the Commission
for Lawyer Discipline, a permanent committee of
the State Bar of Texas.
D. “Committee” means the District
grievance committee.
E. “Complainant” means the person,
firm, corporation, or other entity initiation
a Complaint or Inquiry.
F. “Complaint” means those written
matters received by the Office of the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel that, either on the face thereof or upon
screening or preliminary investigation, allege
Professional Misconduct or attorney Disability,
or both, cognizable under these rules or Texas
Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct.
G. “Director” means a member of the
Board of Directors of the State Bar of Texas.
H. “Disability means any physical, mental,
emotional condition that, with or without a substantive
rule violation, results in the attorney’s
inability to practice law, provide client services,
complete contracts of employment, or otherwise
carry out his or her professional responsibilities
to the clients, courts, the profession, or the
public.
I. “Disciplinary Action” means a proceeding
brought by or against an attorney before an evidentiary
panel of a Committee or any judicial proceeding
covered by these rules.
K. “Disciplinary Proceedings” means
the investigation and processing of an Inquiry
or Complaint before a Disciplinary Action.
L. “District” means disciplinary district.
M. “General Counsel” means the General
Counsel of the State Bar of Texas and any and
all of his or her assistants.
N. “Inquiry” means any written matter
concerning attorney conduct received by the Office
of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel that, even if
true, does not allege Professional Misconduct
or Disability.
O. “Intentional Crime” means (1) any
Serious Crime that requires proof of knowledge
or intent as an essential element or (2) any crime
involving misapplication of money or other property
held as a fiduciary.
P. “Just Cause” means such cause as
is found to exist upon a reasonable inquiry that
would induce a reasonably intelligent and prudent
person to believe that an attorney either has
committed an act or acts of Professional Misconduct
requiring that a Sanction be imposed, or suffers
from a Disability that requires either suspension
as an attorney licensed to practice law in the
State of Texas or probation.
Q. “Professional Misconduct” includes:
1. Acts or omissions by an attorney, individually
or in concert with another person or persons,
that violated one or more of the Texas Disciplinary
Rules of Professional Conduct.
2. Attorney conduct that occurs in another state
or in the District of Columbia and results in
the disciplining of an attorney in that other
jurisdiction, if the conduct is Professional Misconduct
under the Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional
Conduct.
3. Violation of any disciplinary or disability
order of judgment.
4. Failure of the Respondent to furnish information
subpoenaed by a Committee, unless he or she, in
good faith, asserts a privilege or other legal
grounds for the failure to do so.
5. Engaging in conduct that constitutes barratry
as defined by the law of this state.
6. Failure to comply with Section 13.01 of these
rules relating to notification of an attorney’s
cessation of practice.
7. Engaging in the practice of law either during
a period of suspension or when on inactive status.
8. Conviction of a Serious Crime, or being placed
on probation for a Serious Crime with or without
an adjudication of guilt.
9. Conviction of an Intentional Crime, or being
placed on probation for a Intentional Crime with
or without an adjudication of guilt.
R. “Reasonable Attorneys’ Fees,”
for purpose of these rules only, means a reasonable
fee for a competent private attorney, under the
circumstances. Relevant factors that may be considered
in determining the reasonableness of a fee include
but are not limited to the following:
1. The time and labor require, the novelty and
difficulty of the questions involved, and the
skill requisite to perform the legal service properly.
2. The fee customarily charged in the locality
for similar legal services.
3. The amount involved and the results obtained.
4. The time limitations imposed by the circumstances.
5. The experience, reputation, and ability of
the lawyer or lawyers performing the services.
S. “Respondent” means any attorney
who is the subject of a Complaint, Disciplinary
Proceeding, or Disciplinary Action.
T. “Sanction” means any of the following:
1. Disbarment.
2. Resignation in lieu of disbarment.
3. Indefinite Disability suspension.
4. Suspension for a term certain.
5. Probation of suspension, which probation may
be concurrent with the period of suspension, upon
such reasonable terms as are appropriate under
the circumstances.
6. Interim suspension.
7. Public reprimand.
8. Private reprimand.
The term “Sanction” may include the
following additional ancillary requirements:
a. Restitution (which may include repayment to
the Client Security Fund of the State Bar of any
payments made by reason of Respondent’s
Professional Misconduct); and
b. Payment of Reasonable Attorneys’ Fees
and all direct expenses associated with the proceedings.
U. “Serious Crime” means barratry;
any felony involving moral turpitude; any misdemeanor
involving theft, embezzlement, or fraudulent or
reckless misappropriation of money or other property;
or any attempt, conspiracy, or solicitation of
another to commit any of the foregoing crimes.
V. “State Bar” means the State Bar
of Texas.
Part II. The District
Grievance Committees
2.01. Disciplinary Districts and Grievance Committee
Subdistricts
The State of Texas is geographically divided into
disciplinary districts that are coextensive with
the districts of elected Directors of the State
Bar. One or more Committee subdistricts shall
be delineated by the Board within each such District.
From time to time, if the Commission deems it
useful for the efficient operation of the disciplinary
system, it shall recommend to the Board that a
redelineation be made of one or more subdistricts
within a District. All Committees within a single
disciplinary district have concurrent authority
within the District but once a matter has been
assigned to a Committee, that Committee has dominant
jurisdiction, absent a transfer.
2.02. Composition of Members
Each elected Director of the State Bar shall nominate,
and the President of the State Bar shall appoint,
the members of the Committees within the District
that coincides with the Director’s district,
according to rules and policies adopted from time
to time by the Board. Each Committee must consist
of no fewer than nine members, two-thirds of whom
must be attorneys licensed to practice law in
the State of Texas and in good standing, and one-third
of whom must be public members. Each member of
the Committee shall reside within or maintain
his or her principle place of employment or practice
within the District for which appointed. Public
members may not have, other than as consumers,
any financial interest, direct or indirect, in
the practice of law. There may be no ex officio
members of any Committee. Deliberations or discussions
of the Committee on the merits of any grievance
may be conducted only in the presence of the members
of the Committee and the Committees’ counsel.
2.03. Time for Appointment and Terms
All persons serving on the Committee at the time
these rule become effective shall continue to
serve for their then unexpired terms, subject
to resignation or removal as herein provided.
Nominations to Committees shall be made annually
at the spring meeting of the Board; all appointments
shall be made by the President no later than June
1 of each year. If any Director fails or refuses
to make appointments in a timely manner, the existing
members of the Committees shall continue to hold
office until the nominations and appointments
are made and the successor member is qualified.
One-third of each new Committee will be appointed
for initial terms of one year, one-third for an
initial term of two years, and one-third for an
initial term of three years. Thereafter, all terms
will be for a period of three years, except for
appointments to fill unexpired terms, which will
be for the remaining period of the unexpired term.
Any member of a committee who has served two consecutive
terms, whether full or partial terms, is not eligible
for reappointment until at least three years have
passed since his or her last prior service. No
member may serve as chair for more than two consecutive
terms of one year each. All members are eligible
for election to the position of chair.
2.04. Organizational Meeting of Grievances Committees
The last duly elected chair of a Committee shall
call an organizational meeting of the Committee
no later than July 15 of each year; shall administer
the oath of office to each new member; and shall
preside until the Committee has elected, by a
majority vote, its new chair. Members may vote
for themselves for the position of chair.
2.05. Oath of Committee Members
As soon as possible after appointment, each newly
appointed member of a Committee shall take the following
oath to be administered by any person authorized
by law to administer oaths:
“I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will
faithfully execute my duties as a member of the
District grievance committee, as required by the
Texas Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, and will,
to the best of my ability, preserve, protect, and
defend the Constitution and laws of the United States
and of the State of Texas. I further solemnly swear
(or affirm) that I will keep secret all such matters
and things as shall come to my knowledge as a member
of the grievance committee arising from or in connection
with each Disciplinary Action and Disciplinary Proceeding,
unless permitted to disclose the same in accordance
with the Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, or unless
ordered to do so in the course of a judicial proceeding
or a proceeding before the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals. I further solemnly swear (or affirm) that
I have neither directly nor indirectly paid, offered,
or promised to pay, contributed any money or valuable
thing, or promised any public or private office
to secure my appoint. So help me God.”
2.06. Duties of Members
Each member of a Committee shall act through panels
assigned by the chair of the Committee for investigatory
hearings and evidentiary hearings. Promptly after
assignment, notice must be provided to the Respondent
by United States certified mail, return receipt
requested, of the names and addresses of the panel
members assigned to each grievance. A member is
disqualified to sit as a panel member for either
an investigatory hearing or an evidentiary hearing
if a district judge would, under similar circumstances,
be disqualified. If a member is disqualified, another
panel member shall be appointed by the Committee
chair. No peremptory challenges of a panel member
are allowed. Any alleged grounds for disqualification
of a panel member are conclusively waived if not
brought to the attention of the panel within ten
days after receipt of notification of the names
and addresses of members of the panel; however,
grounds for disqualification not reasonably discoverable
within the ten-day period may be asserted within
ten days after they were discovered or in the exercise
of reasonable diligence should have been discovered.
2.07. Duties of Committees
Committees shall act through panels, as assigned
by the Committee chairs, to conduct investigatory
hearing or evidentiary hearings. No panel may consist
of more than one-half of all members of the Committee
or fewer than three members. If a member of a panel
is disqualified or unable to serve, the chair shall
appoint a replacement. Panels must be composed of
two attorney members for each public member. A majority
constitutes a quorum, and business shall be conducted
upon majority vote of those members present, a quorum
being had. In matters in which evidence is taken,
no member may vote unless that member has heard
or reviewed all reviewed all the evidence. It shall
be conclusively presumed, however, not subject to
discovery or challenge in any subsequent proceeding,
that every member casting a vote has heard or reviewed
all the evidence. No member, attorney or public,
may be appointed by the chair in the same matter
for both the investigatory panel and the evidentiary
panel. All committee panels must be randomly selected
by the chair. Any tie vote is a vote in favor of
the position of the Respondent.
2.08. Expenses
Members of Committees serve without compensation
but are entitled to reimbursement by the State Bar
for their reasonable, actual, and necessary expenses.
2.09 Classification of Inquiries and Complaints
Every written statement, from whatever source, apparently
intended to allege Professional Misconduct by a
lawyer, shall be promptly forwarded to the Office
of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel. The Chief Disciplinary
Counsel shall examine each such written statement
to determine whether it constitutes an Inquiry or
a Complaint. In those instances in which the Complaint
alleges a violation that involves no harm to a particular
individual or entity, or with respect to which the
testimony of the individual or entity is not reasonably
anticipated to be necessary, upon request of that
individual or entity initiating the Complaint, a
restated Complaint shall be made in the name of
the Bar without identification of that individual
or entity and furnished to the lawyer in accordance
with these rules. In such cases, the names of the
individual or entity shall remain confidential.
If the statement is determined to constitute an
Inquiry, the Chief Disciplinary Counsel shall notify
the Complainant, who has the right to amend the
statement or, within thirty days after receipt of
the notice, appeal the determination to the Board
of Disciplinary Appeals. Complainants may amend
the statement with additional material for reconsideration
one time only following dismissal by the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel, the Board of Disciplinary Appeals, or the
Committee. If the statement is determined to constitute
a Complaint, the Respondent shall be provided a
copy of the Complaint with notice to respond, in
writing, to the allegations of the Complaint by
delivering the response to the Committee within
thirty days after receipt of the notice. The notice
shall notify the Respondent that the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel may provide appropriate information, including
the Respondent’s response, to law enforcement
agencies as permitted by Rule 6.08. The Chief Disciplinary
Counsel shall then forward the statement to the
Committee. The Respondent may, within thirty days
after receipt of a notice to respond, appeal to
the Board of Disciplinary Appeals the determination
of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel that the statement
constitutes a Complaint. If the Respondent perfects
an appeal, the pendency of the appeal does not automatically
stay the investigation and determination of Just
Cause, but no evidentiary panel may be assigned
while an appeal is pending on the issue of whether
a statement constitutes a Complaint. All proceedings
shall immediately be dismissed if the determination
of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel is reversed and
it is finished that a statement does not constitute
a Complaint.
2.10. Place of Forum
Venue of Committee proceedings shall be in accordance
with the following:
A. Investigatory Panel Proceedings. Proceedings
of an investigatory panel of a Committee shall be
conducted by a Committee for the county where the
alleged Professional Misconduct occurred, in whole
or in part. Any motion by Respondent to transfer,
based upon facts existing at the time the Respondent
receives the notice to respond to the Complaint,
must be filed within twenty days after Respondent’s
receipt of notice to respond. Otherwise, Respondent’s
right to seek transfer based upon such facts is
waived. Any motion to transfer by Complainant must
be made within ten days after receipt of the notice
from the Chief Disciplinary Counsel that the statement
has been classified as a Complaint or Complainant’s
right to seek transfer is waived. Dismissal of a
previous complaint by the Chief Disciplinary Counsel
or Committee shall not be grounds for requesting
transfer to a different region.
B. Evidentiary Panel Proceedings. If the investigatory
panel finds Just Cause and is unable to negotiate
a Sanction acceptable to it and to the Respondent,
or if there is no sufficient Sanction available
to the investigatory panel, the matter shall be
transferred to a Committee for the county of Respondent’s
residence; or if the Respondent maintains neither
a residence nor a place of practice within the State
of Texas, then to the county where the alleged Professional
Misconduct occurred, in whole or in part. In all
other instances, disciplinary actions must take
place in Travis County, Texas.
2.12 Disposition Upon a Failure to Find Just Cause
If no member of the investigatory panel votes in
favor of a finding of Just Cause, the panel shall
forthwith dismiss the Complaint and so advise the
Complainant, the Respondent, and the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel. If any member of the first assigned investigatory
panel votes to find that Just Cause exists, the
Complainant may submit his or her Complaint to a
second investigatory panel of the same Committee
which shall make a de novo determination of whether
Just Cause exists. If a majority of the second investigatory
panel fails to find that Just Cause exists, it shall
forthwith dismiss the Complaint and so advise the
Complainant, the Respondent, and the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel. If any member of the first assigned investigatory
panel votes to find that Just Cause exists, the
Complainant may submit his or her Complaint to a
second investigatory panel of the same Committee,
which shall make a de novo determination of whether
Just Cause exists. If a majority of the second investigatory
panel fails to find that Just Cause exists, it shall
forthwith dismiss the Complaint and so advise the
Complainant, the Respondent, and the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel. Such a dismissal is without prejudice to
the Complainant, who may, within thirty days from
receipt of notice of dismissal, refile his or her
Complaint with additional evidence not previously
presented. Files of dismissed Disciplinary Proceedings
will be retained for one hundred eighty days, after
which time the files may be destroyed unless the
Complainant refiles the Complaint within the permitted
time. No permanent record will be kept of Complaints
dismissed except to the extent necessary for statistical
reporting purposes.
2.13. Disposition Upon a Finding of Just Cause
Should an investigatory panel find Just Cause,
it may, with the consent of Respondent, impose any
Sanction available under these rules except disbarment.
It may also, with or without Sanctions, impose a
referral for rehabilitation with the consent of
Respondent. If a negotiated result is reached, or
if the investigatory panel wishes to offer an agreed
result to the respondent, its terms shall be embodied
in a written judgment which shall contain the findings,
conclusions, Sanctions, or referral for rehabilitation
agreed upon. Such judgment shall promptly be delivered
to Respondent and Respondent shall have 20 days
from receipt of such judgment to sign and return
it to the chief Disciplinary Counsel. If the Chief
Disciplinary Counsel has not received the judgment
signed by the Respondent 20 days after the respondent
received it, the matter shall proceed as if no negotiated
result had been reached. If the investigatory panel
is unable to negotiate a Sanction with the Respondent,
it shall so notify the Complainant and the Respondent
by U.S. certified mail, return receipt requested,
and the matter will proceed. Such notice must include
the following statement: “Further proceedings
shall be conducted before an evidentiary panel of
a District Grievance Committee, in accordance with
the Texas Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, unless
you timely elect, in accordance with Section 2.14
thereof, to have the Complaint heard in a district
court of proper venue, with or without a jury, instead
of by an evidentiary panel of the District Grievance
Committee.” The procedure for making such
an election is as provided in Section 2.14.
2.14. Optional Trial De Novo
If a Respondent is notified, in accordance with
Section 2.13 of a finding of Just Cause and an inability
to negotiate a Sanction, he or she may elect to
have the Complaint heard in a district court of
proper venue, with or without a jury, instead of
by an evidentiary panel of the Committee. The election
must be in writing and served upon the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel no later than fifteen days after the Respondent’s
receipt of written notification pursuant to Section
2.13. If the Respondent timely files such an election,
the matter will proceed in accordance with Part
III hereof. A Respondent’s failure to timely
file an election shall conclusively be deemed as
an affirmative election to proceed in accordance
with Section 2.16.
2.15. Confidentiality
All information, proceedings, hearing transcripts,
statements, and any other information coming to
the attention of the investigatory panel of the
Committee must remain confidential and may not be
disclosed to any person or entity (except the Chief
Disciplinary Counsel) unless disclosure is ordered
by the court. If there is a finding of Just Cause
and any Sanction other than a private reprimand
(which may include restitution and payment of Attorneys’
Fees) imposed by agreement of the Respondent, all
of the information, proceedings, hearing transcripts,
documents, statements, and other information coming
to the attention of the investigatory panel shall
be, upon, proper request, made public. Notwithstanding
anything herein to the contrary, any action taken
by a Committee to refer a matter to the Board of
Disciplinary Appeals for attorney Disability screening
and determination must remain confidential.
2.16. Evidentiary Hearings
If the investigatory panel of the Committee finds
Just Cause and if the Respondent fails to elect
to have the Complaint tried in the district court,
the matter may be transferred, if necessary, in
accordance with the venue provisions of these rules.
The chair of the Committee to which the matter is
transferred shall appoint an evidentiary panel to
conduct an evidentiary hearing, to make findings
of fact and conclusions of law, and either to dismiss
the Complaint or to impose Sanctions. The evidentiary
panel may not include any person who served on the
investigatory panel and must have at least three
members but must have no more than one-half as many
members as on the Committee. Each evidentiary panel
must have a ratio of two lawyers for every public
member. Proceedings before an evidentiary panel
of the Committee include:
A. Service upon the Respondent of a written statement
of the specific charge or charges against the Respondent,
together with a copy of the Complaint. The charge
shall be formulated by the evidentiary panel on
the basis of the findings of the investigatory panel.
The notification shall be given by the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel and shall be served by U.S. certified mail,
return receipt requested, upon the Respondent or
upon his or her attorney, if an attorney has entered
an appearance before the Committee on behalf of
the Respondent, or by any other means of service
permitted by the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure.
At the time of service upon the Respondent, the
Chief Disciplinary counsel shall also file with
the Committee and serve upon the Respondent a proposed
hearing order containing at least the following:
1. A list, including names, addresses, and telephone
numbers of all witnesses expected to be called to
testify before the panel in person or by deposition.
2. A written summary of the issues of fact expected
to be contested.
3. A list of exhibits expected to be presented to
the panel at the hearing.
4. Written summaries of the testimony expected to
be elicited from each witness.
5. The estimated length of time for presenting the
entire case to the panel.
B. A responsive pleading either admitting or denying
each specific charge must be filed by or on behalf
of the Respondent within twenty days after the date
of service of the notification of the specific charge
or charges against the Respondent. At the time of
filing the responsive pleading, Respondent shall
also file a proposed hearing order containing any
modifications that the Respondent desires to make
to the proposed hearing order filed by the Chief
Disciplinary Counsel. Any failure to file such a
responsive pleading and proposed hearing order within
the time permitted constitutes a default, and all
facts alleged in the charging document shall be
taken as true for the purposes of the Disciplinary
Action unless:
(i) within seven days after receipt of notice
of such default, Respondent files a verified motion
reflecting good cause for failing to timely file
a responsive pleading and proposed hearing order
and files, subject to leave being granted, a responsive
pleading and proposed hearing order; and
(ii) the evidentiary panel finds that good cause
exists for Respondent’s failure to have timely
filed a responsive pleading and proposed hearing
order.
C. The final hearing order may be amended for good
cause shown at the discretion of the chair, and
shall control the hearing. If the final hearing
order differs from the proposed hearing order filed
by the Respondent, Respondent may, by filing a written
request with the chair and the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel within ten days after the date of actual
receipt of the final hearing order, remove the case
to a court of proper venue for a trial de novo under
Part III.
D. Compulsory process to compel the attendance of
witnesses, enforceable by an order of a district
court of proper jurisdiction, is available to the
Respondent and to the Chief Disciplinary Counsel.
E. The Respondent and the Complainant may, if they
so choose, have counsel present during any evidentiary
hearing.
F. The Respondent, the Complainant and the Chief
Disciplinary Counsel may, if they so choose, confront
witnesses, including the Complainant. Cross-examination
may be conducted only by the Respondent, or his
or her counsel, and by the Chief Disciplinary Counsel.
The inability or failure to exercise this opportunity
does not abate or preclude further proceedings.
G. In the discretion of the evidentiary panel, limited
discovery is permissible upon a clear showing of
good cause and substantial need. The party seeking
discovery must file with the evidentiary panel a
verified written request for discovery showing good
cause and substantial need no later than twenty
days after the filing of, or the time for the filing
of, the first responsive pleading by the Respondent.
If good cause and substantial need are demonstrated,
the panel shall by written order permit the discovery,
including in the order any limitations or deadlines
on the discovery. Such discovery, if any, as may
be permitted must be conducted by the methods provided
by the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure in effect
at the time any may, upon motion, be enforced by
a district court of proper jurisdiction. A decision
of an evidentiary panel on a discovery matter may
be reviewed only on appeal of the entire case. No
reversal of a case may be based on the granting
or denial of a discovery request without a showing
of material unfairness or harm.
H. The presiding member of the evidentiary panel
shall admit all such probative and relevant evidence
as he or she deems necessary for a fair and complete
hearing, generally in accord with the Texas Rules
of Civil Evidence; provided, however, that admission
or exclusion of evidence shall be in the discretion
of the presiding member of the evidentiary panel
and no ruling upon the evidence shall be a basis
for reversal solely because it fails to strictly
comply with the Texas Rules of Civil Evidence.
I. The burden of proof is upon the Complainant and
the Chief Disciplinary Counsel to prove the material
allegations of the charge by a preponderance of
the evidence.
J. A verbatim record of the proceedings will be
made by a certified short-hand reporter in a manner
prescribed by the Board of Disciplinary Appeals.
In the event of an appeal from the evidentiary panel
to the Board of Disciplinary Appeals, the party
initiating the appeal shall pay the costs of preparation
of the transcript. Such costs shall be taxed at
the conclusion of the appeal by the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals.
K. All proceedings before an evidentiary panel,
except its deliberations, are open to the public.
L. A written decision by the evidentiary panel must
be issued promptly after the consummation of evidence.
Matters must be set for hearing on a date not sooner
than forty-five days nor later than ninety days
after the filing of the responsive pleading of the
Respondent. If the Respondent fails to answer, a
hearing for default may be set at any time no less
than ten days from the date which Respondent received
his notice of default. No continuance may be granted
unless required by the interests of justice.
M. Written findings of fact, conclusions of law,
and any Sanctions shall be issued by the evidentiary
panel within thirty days after the conclusion of
the evidentiary hearing.
2.17. Imposition of Sanctions
If the evidentiary panel finds that a Sanction should
be assessed against the Respondent, the written
order of the evidentiary panel shall assess the
Sanction. The evidentiary panel may, in its discretion,
conduct a separate evidentiary hearing on the appropriate
Sanction to be imposed. Private reprimand is not
an available Sanction in a hearing before an evidentiary
panel. In imposing any Sanctions, the evidentiary
panel shall consider:
A. The nature and degree of the Professional Misconduct
for which the Respondent is being sanctioned.
B. The seriousness of and circumstances surrounding
the Professional Misconduct.
C. The loss or damage to clients.
D. The damage to the profession.
E. The assurance that those who seek legal services
in the future will be insulated from the type of
Professional Misconduct found.
F. The profit to the attorney.
G. The avoidance of repetition.
H. The deterrent effect on others.
I. The maintenance of respect for the legal profession.
J. The conduct of the Respondent during the course
of the Committee action.
In addition, the Respondent’s disciplinary
record, including any private reprimands is admissible
on the appropriate Sanction to be imposed. Respondent’s
Disability resulting from the use of alcohol or
drugs may not be considered in mitigation, unless
Respondent demonstrates that he or she is successfully
pursuing in good faith a program of recovery.
2.18. Restitution
In all cases in which the proof establishes that
the Respondent’s misconduct involved the misappropriation
of funds and the Respondent is disbarred or suspended,
the panel’s judgment must require the Respondent
to make restitution during the period of suspension,
or before any consideration of reinstatement from
disbarment, and must further provide that its judgment
of suspension shall remain in effect until evidence
of satisfactory restitution is made by Respondent
and verified by Chief Disciplinary Counsel.
2.19. Notice of Decision
The Complainant, Respondent, and Chief Disciplinary
Counsel must be notified in writing of the decision
of the evidentiary panel, including any Sanctions
imposed. Such notice shall be mailed by U.S. certified
mail, return receipt requested, to the Complainant,
Respondent, and the Chief Disciplinary Counsel.
The notice must clearly state that any appeal of
the findings, conclusions, or Sanctions must be
made in writing within thirty days of the date of
the notice. If the panel finds that the Respondent
committed professional misconduct, a copy of the
charge as defined in Section 2.16 of the Texas Rules
of Disciplinary Procedure, and the final judgment
shall be transmitted by the Office of the Chief
Disciplinary Counsel to the Clerk of the Supreme
Court.
2.20. Probated Suspension—Revocation Procedure
If all or any part of a suspension from the practice
of law is probated under this Part II, the Board
of Disciplinary Appeals is hereby granted jurisdiction
for the full term of suspension, including any probationary
period, to hear a motion to revoke probation. If
the Chief Disciplinary Counsel files a motion to
revoke probation, it shall be set for hearing within
thirty days of service of the motion upon the Respondent.
Service upon the Respondent shall be sufficient
if made in accordance with Rule 21a of the Texas
Rules of Civil Procedure. Upon proof, by a preponderance
of the evidence, of a violation of probation, the
same shall be revoked and the attorney suspended
from the practice of law for the full term of suspension
without credit for any probationary time served.
The Board of Disciplinary Appeals’ Order revoking
a probated suspension cannot be superseded or stayed.
2.21. Appeals by Complainant, Respondent or Chief
Disciplinary Counsel
The Complainant, Respondent, or Chief Disciplinary
Counsel may appeal to the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals any findings, conclusions, or Sanctions
imposed by an evidentiary panel. Such appeals must
be on the record, determined under the standard
of substantial evidence. Briefs may be filed as
a matter of right. The time deadlines for such briefs
shall be promulgated by the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals. The Complainant is entitled to the reasonable
assistance of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel in
any appeal; but the Chief Disciplinary Counsel is
not obligated to assist the Complainant in matters
considered by Chief Disciplinary Counsel to be without
merit.
A. An appeal, if taken, must be commenced by the
filing with the Board of Disciplinary Appeals of
a Notice of Appeal within thirty days from Respondent’s
receipt of the decision of the evidentiary panel
from which the appeal is made. The Notice of Appeal
must reflect the intention of the Respondent to
appeal and identify the decision from which appeal
is perfected.
B. An evidentiary panel’s order of disbarment
cannot be superseded or stayed. An order of suspension
must be stayed during the pendency of any appeals
therefrom if the evidentiary panel finds, upon competent
evidence, that the Respondent’s continued
practice of law does not pose a continuing threat
to the welfare of Respondent’s clients or
to the public. An evidentiary panel may condition
its stay upon reasonable terms, which may include,
but are not limited to, the cessation of any practice
found to constitute Professional Misconduct, or
it may impose a requirement of an affirmative act
such as an audit of a Respondent’s client
trust account.
PART III. TRIAL DE NOVO
IN THE DISTRICT COURT
3.01. Disciplinary Petition
If the Respondent timely files an election for
trial de novo in accordance with Section 2.14, the
Chief Disciplinary Counsel shall file a Disciplinary
Petition in the name of the Commission. The petition
must contain:
A. Notice that the action is brought by the Commission
for Lawyer Discipline, a committee of the State
Bar.
B. The name of the Respondent and the fact that
he or she is an attorney licensed to practice law
in the State of Texas.
C. The residence and principal place of practice
of the Respondent, or other allegations necessary
to fix venue.
D. A description of the acts and conduct that gave
rise to the alleged professional Misconduct in detail
sufficient to give fair notice to Respondent of
the claims made, which factual allegations may be
grouped in one or more counts.
E. The specific rules of the Disciplinary Rules
of Professional Conduct allegedly violated by the
acts or conduct, or other grounds for seeking Sanctions.
F. A demand for judgment that the Respondent be
disciplined as warranted by the facts and for any
other appropriated relief.
G. Any other matter that is required or may be permitted
by law or by these rules.
The Disciplinary Petition must be filed with the
Clerk of the Supreme Court of Texas.
3.02. Assignment of Judge
Upon receipt of a Disciplinary Petition, the Clerk
of the Supreme Court of Texas shall docket the same
and promptly bring the Petition to the attention
of the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court shall promptly
appoint an active district judge who does not reside
in the Administrative Judicial Region in which the
Respondent resides to preside in the case. Should
the judge so appointed by unable to fulfill the
appointment, he or she shall immediately notify
the Clerk of the Supreme Court, and the Supreme
Court shall appoint a replacement judge. The judge
appointed shall be subject to recusal under the
Rules of Civil Procedure and objection, as provided
by law, through a motion filed by either party not
later than sixty (60) days from the date the Respondent
is served with the Supreme Court’s order appointing
the judge, provided that in the event of recusal
or valid objection, the Supreme Court shall appoint
the replacement judge within thirty (30) days of
the order of recusal.
3.03. Filing, Service and Venue
After the trial judge has been appointed, the Clerk
of the Supreme Court shall promptly forward the
Disciplinary Petition and a copy of the Supreme
Court’s appointing Order to the district clerk
of the county of alleged venue. Upon receipt of
the Disciplinary Petition and copy of the Supreme
Court’s appointing Order, the district clerk
shall transmit a copy of the Supreme Court’s
appointing Order to the Chief Disciplinary Counsel.
The Respondent shall be served as in civil cases
generally with a copy of the Disciplinary Petition
and a copy of the Supreme Court’s appointing
Order. All proceedings incident to the trial de
novo must take place in the county of Respondent’s
principal place of practice, or if the Respondent
does not maintain a place of practice within the
State of Texas, to the county of Respondent’s
residence or the county where the alleged Professional
Misconduct occurred in whole or in part.
3.04. Answer of the Respondent
The answer of the Respondent must follow the form
of answers in civil cases generally and must be
filed no later than 10:00 a.m. on the first Monday
following the expiration of twenty days after service
upon the Respondent.
3.05. Discovery
Discovery is to be conducted as in civil cases
generally, except that the following matters are
not discoverable:
A. The discussions, thought processes, and individual
votes of the members of the Committee.
B. The thought processes of the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel.
C. Any communication to or from the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel that would be privileged in the case of
a private attorney representing a private litigant.
3.06. Trial by Jury
In a Disciplinary Action, either the Respondent
or the Commission shall have the right to a jury
trial upon timely payment of the required fee and
compliance with the provisions of Rule 216, Texas
Rules of Civil Procedure. The Complainant has no
right to demand a jury trial.
3.07. Trial Setting
The court shall set each Disciplinary Action to
commence the trial no later than 180 days after
the date the Disciplinary Petition is filed with
the district clerk. No motion for continuance, resetting,
or agreed pass may be granted unless required by
the interests of justice. Mandamus lies to enforce
this rule upon the petition of the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel or the Respondent.
3.08. Additional Rules of Procedure in the Trial
of Disciplinary Actions
In all Disciplinary Actions brought under this
part, the following additional rules apply:
A. Disciplinary Actions are civil in nature.
B. Except as varied by these rules, the Texas Rules
of Civil Procedure apply.
C. Disciplinary Actions must be proved by a preponderance
of the evidence.
D. The burden of proof in a Disciplinary Action
seeking Sanction or discipline due to Disability
is on the Commission. The burden of proof in reinstatement
cases is upon the applicant.
E. The parties to a Disciplinary Action may not
seek abatement or delay of trial because of substantial
similarity to the material allegations in any other
pending civil or criminal case.
F. The unwillingness or neglect of a Complainant
to sign a Complaint or to assist in the prosecution
of a Disciplinary Action, or a compromise and settlement
between the Complainant and the Respondent, does
not alone justify the abatement or dismissal of
the action.
G. It shall be the policy of the Commission to participate
in alternative dispute resolution procedures where
feasible; provided however that Disciplinary Actions
shall be exempt from any requirements of mandatory
alternative dispute resolution procedures as provided
by Chapter 154 of the Civil Practice and Remedies
Code or as otherwise provided by law.
3.09. Judgment
If the trial court fails to find from the evidence
in a case tried without a jury, or from the verdict
in a jury trial, that the Respondent’s conduct
constitutes Professional Misconduct, the court shall
render judgment accordingly. If the court finds
that the Respondent’s conduct does constitute
Professional Misconduct, the court shall determine
the appropriate Sanction or Sanctions to be imposed.
If the court finds that the Respondent committed
an act or acts of Professional Misconduct, the court
shall direct transmittal of certified copies of
the judgment and all trial pleadings to the Clerk
of the Supreme Court. The Clerk of the Supreme Court
shall make an appropriate notation on the Respondent’s
permanent record. The trial court shall promptly
enter judgment after the close of evidence (in the
case of a nonjury trial) or after the return of
the jury’s verdict. Mandamus lies in the Supreme
Court of Texas to enforce this provision, upon the
petition of either the Respondent or the Chief Disciplinary
counsel.
3.10 Hearing on Sanctions
The trial court may, in its discretion, conduct
a separate evidentiary hearing on the appropriate
Sanction or Sanctions to be imposed. In imposing
the Sanction or Sanctions, the court shall consider:
A. The nature and degree of the Professional Misconduct
for which the Respondent is being sanctioned.
B. The seriousness of and circumstances surrounding
the Professional Misconduct.
C. The loss or damage to clients.
D. The damage to the profession.
E. The assurance that those who seek legal services
in the future will be insulated from the type of
Professional Misconduct found.
F. The profit to the attorney.
G. The avoidance of repetition.
H. The deterrent effect on others.
I. The maintenance of respect for the legal profession.
J. The conduct of the Respondent during the course
of the Committee action.
K. The trial of the case.
L. Other relevant evidence concerning the Respondent’s
personal and professional background.
In addition, the Respondent’s disciplinary
record, including any private reprimands, is admissible
on the appropriate Sanction to be imposed. Respondent’s
Disability resulting from the use of alcohol or
drugs may not be considered in mitigation, unless
Respondent demonstrates that he or she is successfully
pursuing in good faith a program of recovery.
3.11. Terms of Judgment
In any judgment of disbarment or suspension that
is not stayed, the court shall order the Respondent
to surrender his or her law license and permanent
State Bar card to Chief Disciplinary Counsel for
transmittal to the Clerk of the Supreme Court. In
all judgments imposing disbarment or suspension,
the court shall enjoin the Respondent from practicing
law or from holding himself or herself out as an
attorney capable of practicing law during the period
of disbarment or suspension. In all judgments of
disbarment, suspension, or reprimand, the court
shall make all other orders as it finds appropriate,
including probation of all or any portion of suspension.
The continuing jurisdiction of the trial court to
enforce a judgment does not give a trial court authority
to terminate or reduce a period of active suspension
previously ordered.
3.12. Restitution
In all cases in which the proof establishes that
the Respondent’s conduct involved misapplication
of funds and the judgment is one disbarring or suspending
the Respondent, the judgment must require the Respondent
to make restitution during the period of suspension,
or before any consideration of reinstatement from
disbarment, and shall further provide that a judgment
of suspension shall remain in effect until proof
is made of complete restitution.
3.13. Probation Suspension—Revocation Procedure
If all or any part of a suspension from the practice
of law is probated under this Part III, the court
retains jurisdiction during the full term of suspension,
including any probationary period, to hear a motion
to revoke probation. If the Chief Disciplinary Counsel
files a motion to revoke probation, it shall be
set for hearing before the court without the aid
of a jury within thirty days of service of the motion
upon the Respondent. Service upon the Respondent
shall be sufficient if made in accordance with Rule
21a of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure. Upon
proof by a preponderance of the evidence of a violation
of probation, the same shall be revoked and the
attorney suspended from the practice of law for
the full term of suspension without credit for any
probationary time served.
3.14. No Supersedeas
A district court judgment of disbarment or an order
revoking probation of a suspension from the practice
of law cannot be superseded or stayed. A judgment
of suspension shall be stayed during the pendency
of any appeals therefrom, if the district court
finds, upon competent evidence, that the Respondent’s
continued practice of law does not pose a continuing
threat to the welfare of Respondent’s clients
or to the public. The district court may condition
its stay upon reasonable terms, which may include,
but are not limited to, the cessation of any practice
found to constitute Professional Misconduct, or
it may impose a requirement of an affirmative act
such as an audit of a Respondent’s client
trust account. There is no interlocutory appeal
from a court’s stay of a suspension, with
or without conditions.
3.15. Exemption from Cost and Appeal Bond
No cost or appeal bond is required of the Chief
Disciplinary Counsel or the Commission. In lieu
thereof, when a cost or appeal bond would be otherwise
required, a memorandum setting forth the exemption
under this rule, when filed, suffices as a cost
or appeal bond.
3.16. Appeals
A final judgment of the district court and any order
revoking or refusing to revoke probation of a suspension
from the practice of law may be appealed as in civil
cases generally.
PART IV. THE COMMISSION FOR LAWYER DISCIPLINE
4.01. Composition and Membership
The Commission for Lawyer Discipline is hereby
created as a permanent committee of the State Bar
and is not subject to dissolution by the Board under
Article VIII of the State Bar Rules. The Commission
must be composed of nine members. Six members shall
be attorneys licensed to practice law in the State
of Texas and in good standing as members of the
State Bar. Three members shall be public members
who have, other than as consumers, no interest,
direct or indirect, in the practice of law or the
profession of law. No member of the Commission may
serve as a member of the Commission while he or
she is a member of a Committee, an officer or Director
of the State Bar, an employee of the State Bar,
an officer or director of the Texas Young Lawyers
Association; provided, however, the Chairman of
the Board of the State Bar shall appoint a Director
of the State Bar as an adviser to the Commission
and a Director of the State Bar as an alternate
adviser to the Commission, and the President of
the Texas Young Lawyers Association shall appoint
a director of the Texas Young Lawyers Association
as an adviser to the Commission. Members of the
Commission and its advisers will be compensated
for their reasonable, actual, and necessary expenses,
and members, but not advisers, will be compensated
for their work as determined by the Board to be
appropriate.
4.02. Appointment and Terms
Except for initial appointments as set forth in
Section 4.03 hereof, Commission members will serve
three-year terms unless sooner terminated through
disqualification, resignation, or other cause. Terms
begin on September 1 of the year and expire on August
31 of the third year thereafter. The lawyer members
of the Commission are appointed by the President
of the State Bar, subject to the Board’s concurrence,
no later than June 1 of the year. The public members
are appointed by the Supreme Court, but only for
good cause. Vacancies are to be filled in the same
manner as term appointments but are only for the
unexpired term of the position vacated. Members
of the Commission are not eligible for reappointment
to more than one additional three-year term.
4.03. Initial Appointments
Two lawyers shall initially be appointed for a term
to expire on August 31 after at least twelve months
of service; two lawyers shall initially be appointed
for a term to expire on August 31 after twenty-four
months of service; and two lawyers shall initially
be appointed for a term to expire on August 31 after
thirty-six months of service. One public member
shall initially be appointed for a term to expire
on August 31 after at least twelve months of service;
one public member shall initially be appointed for
a term to expire on August 31 after twenty-four
months of service; and one public member shall initially
be appointed for a term to expire on August 31 after
thirty-six months of service. After the terms provided
above, all terms shall be as provided in Section
4.02.
4.04. Oath of Committee Members
As soon as possible after appointment, each newly
appointed member of the Commission for Lawyer Discipline
shall take the following oath to be administered
by any person authorized by law to administer oaths:
“I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will
faithfully execute my duties as a member of the
Commission for Lawyer Discipline, as required by
the Texas Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, and will,
to the best of my ability, preserve, protect, and
defend the Constitution and laws of the United States
and of the State of Texas. I further solemnly swear
(or affirm) that I will keep secret all such matters
and things as shall come to my knowledge as a member
of the Commission for Lawyer Discipline arising
from or in connection with each Disciplinary Action
and Disciplinary Proceeding unless permitted to
disclose the same in accordance with the Rules of
Disciplinary Procedure or unless ordered to do so
in the course of a judicial proceeding or a proceeding
before the Board of Disciplinary Appeals. I further
solemnly swear (or affirm) that I have neither directly
nor indirectly paid, offered, or promised to pay,
contributed any money or valuable thing, or promised
any public or private office to secure my appointment.
So help me God.”
4.05. Chair
The President of the State Bar, subject to the concurrence
of the Board, shall annually designate a lawyer
member to chair the Commission and another member
to serve as vice-chair, each for a one-year term.
4.06. Duties and Authority of the Commission
The Commission has the following duties and responsibilities:
A. To exercise, in lawyer disciplinary and disability
proceedings only, all rights characteristically
reposed in a client by the common law of this State,
except where such rights are expressly hereby granted
to a Committee. Each Committee possesses all rights
characteristically reposed in a client by the common
law of this State relative to Complaints being handled
by such Committee until either: (i) twenty days
after a Just Cause determination has been made;
or (ii) a Disciplinary Action is filed in a court
of competent jurisdiction.
B. To monitor and, from time to time as appropriate,
to evaluate and report to the Board on the performance
of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel.
C. To retain special counsel or local counsel when
necessary.
D. To recommend to the Board such educational programs
on legal ethics and lawyer discipline as it may
consider advisable.
E. To conduct all of its meetings in such a manner
as to protect the rights of confidentiality to the
extent possible but also to conduct its meetings
in accordance with the Texas Open Meetings Act,
Art. 6252-17, Tex.Rev.Civ.Stat.Ann.
F. To recommend to the Board an annual budget for
the operation of the attorney professional disciplinary
and disability system.
G. To meet monthly or at such other times, in such
places, and for such periods of time as the business
of the Commission requires.
H. To draft and recommend for adoption to the Board
the Commission’s internal operating rules
and procedures, which rules and procedures, as adopted
by the Board, will then be submitted to the Supreme
Court for approval, and after approval, be published
in the Texas Bar Journal.
I. To recommend to the Board the removal, for cause,
of members of Committees.
J. To refer to an appropriate disability screening
committee information coming to its attention indicating
that an attorney is disabled physically, mentally,
or emotionally, or by the use or abuse of alcohol
or other drugs.
K. To report to the Board, at each regular meeting,
and to the Grievance Oversight Committee, at least
annually, on the state of the attorney professional
disciplinary and disability system and to make recommendations
and proposals to the Board on the refinement and
improvement of the system.
L. To formulate and recommend to the Board for adoption
a system for monitoring disabled lawyers.
M. To notify each jurisdiction in which an attorney
is admitted to practice law of any Sanction imposed
in this State, other than a private reprimand (which
may include restitution and payment of Attorneys’
Fees), and any disability suspension, resignation,
and reinstatement.
N. To provide statistics and reports on lawyer discipline
to the National Discipline Data Bank maintained
by the American Bar Association.
O. To maintain, subject to the limitations elsewhere
herein provided, permanent records of disciplinary
and disability matters; and to transmit notice of
all public discipline imposed against an attorney,
suspensions due to Disability, and reinstatements
to the National Discipline Data Bank maintained
by the American Bar Association.
P. To make recommendations to the Board on the establishment
and maintenance of regional offices as required
for the expeditious handling of Inquiries, Complaints,
and other disciplinary matters.
4.07. Conference Calls
The Commission may, at the instance of the chair,
conduct its business, when to do so would not violate
the Open Meetings Act,1 by conference telephone
calls but, in such event, any action taken must
be reduced to writing and signed by each participant
certifying the accuracy of the written record of
action taken.
4.08. Funding
The State Bar shall allocate sufficient funds to
pay all reasonable and necessary expenses incurred
in the discharge of the duties of the Commission;
of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel; of the Board
of Disciplinary Appeals; of Committees and their
individual members; and of witnesses. Further, the
State Bar shall allocate funds to pay all other
reasonable and necessary expenses to administer
the disciplinary and disability system effectively
and efficiently.
PART V. CHIEF DISCIPLINARY COUNSEL
5.01. Selection
The General Counsel of the State Bar shall, subject
to the provisions of this section, serve as the
Chief Disciplinary Counsel under these rules. If
the Commission determines that the General Counsel
of the State Bar should no longer function as the
Chief Disciplinary Counsel, then the Commission
shall notify the Board of such decision and, in
the next succeeding fiscal year of the State Bar,
funds shall be provided to the Commission sufficient
for it to select and hire a lawyer as Chief Disciplinary
Counsel and sufficient deputies and assistants as
may be required to operate the disciplinary and
disability system effectively and efficiently. The
Commission’s determination must be made, if
at all, and the notification herein provided must
be given, if at all, during the months of January
or February 1993, or during the same months of any
odd numbered year thereafter. In such event, the
Commission shall alone possess the right of selection,
but nothing herein precludes its employment of the
General Counsel or a member of the General Counsel’s
staff for such positions.
5.02. Duties
In addition to the other disciplinary duties set
forth in these rules, the Chief Disciplinary Counsel
shall:
A. Review and screen all information coming to his
or her attention or to the attention of the Commission
relating to lawyer misconduct. Such review may encompass
whatever active investigation is deemed necessary
by the Chief Disciplinary Counsel independent of
the filing of a writing.
B. Reject all matters and Inquiries not constituting
a Complaint and so advise the Complainant.
C. Investigate Complaints upon the request of the
Committee and present them to the appropriate Committee
for a Just Cause determination.
D. Recommend dismissal of a Complaint, if appropriate,
to the proper Committee.
E. Move the Board of Disciplinary Appeals to transfer
a pending Disciplinary Proceeding from one Committee
to another within the same District if the Committee
fails or refuses to hear the Disciplinary Proceeding.
F. Move the Board of Disciplinary Appeals to transfer
matters from one Committee to another, whether or
not within the same District, when the requirements
of fairness to the Complainant or the Respondent
require.
G. Upon finding of Just Cause, recommend to the
Committee, as appropriate, either a negotiated Sanction
or the further prosecution of a Complaint.
H. When information regarding a Complaint becomes
eligible for public disclosure under these rules,
refer a Complaint and information related thereto
to any other professional organizations or bodies
that he or she deems appropriate for consultation
on the nature of the Complaint, the events giving
rise to the Complaint, and the proper manner of
resolution of the Complaint. The Chief Disciplinary
Counsel shall provide Respondent written notice
of the referral at the time it is made. Neither
the Chief Disciplinary Counsel nor any person or
body acting under these rules is bound by any recommendation
of another professional organization to which the
Complaint or related information is referred under
this Section.
I. Present cases to evidentiary panels of Committees,
or in a district court if such has been elected
by the Respondent, as provided in these rules, unless
disqualified from doing so under the Texas Disciplinary
Rules of Professional Conduct.
J. Represent the Commission, if the need arises,
before all courts and administrative bodies.
K. Notify the Respondent and the Complainant promptly
of the disposition of each Complaint.
L. Upon receiving information of a violation of
any term or condition of probation by an attorney
suspended from the practice of law where all or
any part of the suspension has been probated, file
on behalf of the Commission a motion to revoke probation.
The motion must state the terms or conditions of
the probation and the conduct alleged to violate
the same. The Chief Disciplinary Counsel shall cause
a copy of the motion to be served on the attorney
involved.
M. Perform such other duties relating to disciplinary
and disability matters, as may be assigned by the
Commission.
5.03. Accountability
On disciplinary and disability matters, the Chief
Disciplinary Counsel is accountable only to the
Commission except where the rights of a client are
exercisable by a Committee, and in such latter instances
the Chief Disciplinary Counsel is accountable solely
to the Committee possessing the rights of the client
with respect to such matter. The Chief Disciplinary
Counsel is not disqualified from representation
of the Commission for Lawyer Discipline in any grievance
proceeding by virtue of having earlier represented
the Committee in the same matter or Complaint.
PART VI. PUBLIC INFORMATION AND ACCESS
6.01. Availability of Materials
The Commission shall ensure that sufficient copies
of these rules, the Texas Disciplinary Rules of
Professional Conduct, and forms for the filing of
disciplinary Inquiries and Complaints are made available
to the public. In addition, the Commission shall
make available to the public a brochure, summarizing
in plain language, the disciplinary and disability
system for attorneys in the State of Texas. Such
brochure shall be made available in English and
in Spanish.
6.02. Public and Media Inquiries
The Commission shall respond, as appropriate, to
all public and media inquiries concerning the operation
of the attorney professional disciplinary and disability
system, but in so doing may not disclose information
that is confidential or privileged. The Commission
shall disclose, upon proper request, information
in its custody or control that is neither confidential
nor privileged. Any attorney may waive confidentiality
and privilege as to his or her disciplinary record
by filing an appropriate waiver on a form to be
prescribed by the Commission. The Commission shall
maintain complete records and files of all disciplinary
and disability matters and compile reports and statistics
to aid in the administration of the system.
6.03. Telephone Inquiries
The Commission shall maintain a toll-free telephone
number. The toll-free number shall be publicized
to ensure that all Texas residents have access to
it. Telephone inquiries about specific attorney
conduct will not be taken, but the Commission will
send a Complaint form to any person or entity inquiring
by telephone.
6.04. Abstracts of Appeals
Any Disciplinary Action appealed to the Board of
Disciplinary Appeals or to a court shall be abstracted
by the Chief Disciplinary Counsel. A copy of the
abstract shall be made available to any person or
other entity upon proper request and shall be published
in the Texas Bar Journal. No information that is
otherwise confidential may be disclosed in an abstract
under these provisions.
6.05. Report to the Clerk of the Supreme Court
The final disposition of any Disciplinary Proceeding
or Disciplinary Action resulting in the imposition
of a Sanction other than a private reprimand (which
may include restitution and payment of Attorneys’
Fees) shall be reported by the Commission to the
Clerk of the Supreme Court of Texas.
6.06. Publication of Court Opinions
All cases involving the Professional Misconduct
or Disability of an attorney appealed to the Courts
of Appeal or to the Supreme Court of Texas must
be published in the official reporter system. This
provision takes precedence over Rule 90, Texas Rules
of Appellate Procedure.
6.07. Publication of Disciplinary Records
The final disposition of all Disciplinary Proceedings
and Disciplinary Actions shall be reported in the
Texas Bar Journal, and shall be sent for publication
to a newspaper of general circulation in the county
of the disciplined attorney’s residence or
office. Private reprimands (which may include restitution
and payment of Attorneys’ Fees) shall be published
in the Texas Bar Journal with the name of the attorney
deleted. The Commission shall report all public
discipline imposed against an attorney, suspensions
due to Disability, and reinstatements to the National
Discipline Data Bank of the American Bar Association.
6.08. Access to Confidential Information
No officer (except the General Counsel when acting
in the capacity of Chief Disciplinary Counsel) or
Director of the State Bar or any appointed adviser
to the Commission shall have access to any confidential
records, information, or proceedings relating to
any Disciplinary Proceeding, Disciplinary Action,
or Disability suspension. The Chief Disciplinary
Counsel may provide appropriate information to law
enforcement agencies and the Supreme Court’s
Unauthorized Practice of Law Committee and its subcommittees.
PART VII. BOARD OF DISCIPLINARY APPEALS
7.01. Membership
The Board of Disciplinary Appeals is hereby established.
Its members shall be appointed by the Supreme Court
of Texas. The Board of Disciplinary Appeals shall
consist of twelve lawyer members with not more than
eight of such members being residents of Harris,
Dallas, Tarrant, Travis, or Bexar Counties, Texas,
and with no more than two members from any one county.
The term of office of all members of the Board of
Disciplinary Appeals shall be for three years. Members
are eligible for appointment to one additional three-year
term. Members appointed to fill an unexpired term
shall be eligible for reappointment for two subsequent
terms. Vacancies shall be filled by appointment
of the Supreme Court of Texas. Each member shall
continue to perform the duties of office until his
or her successor is duly qualified. No person may
simultaneously be a member of the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals and either the Commission, the Board, or
a Committee.
7.02. Initial Appointments
Three lawyers shall initially be appointed for a
term to expire on August 31 after at least twelve
months of service; three lawyers shall initially
be appointed for a term to expire on August 31 after
twenty-four months of service; and three lawyers
shall initially be appointed for a term to expire
on August 31 after thirty-six months of service.
After the terms provided above, all terms shall
be as provided in Section 7.01.
7.03. Election of Officers
The Board of Disciplinary Appeals shall annually
elect members as chair and vice-chair. The chair,
or in his or her absence the vice-chair, shall perform
the duties normally associated with that office
and shall preside over all en banc meetings of the
Board of Disciplinary Appeals.
7.04. Oath of Committee Members
As soon as possible after appointment, each newly
appointed member of the Board of Disciplinary Appeals
shall take the following oath to be administered
by any person authorized by law to administer oaths:
“I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will
faithfully execute my duties as a member of the
Board of Disciplinary Appeals, as required by the
Texas Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, and will,
to the best of my ability, preserve, protect, and
defend the Constitution and laws of the United States
and of the State of Texas. I further solemnly swear
(or affirm) that I will keep secret all such matters
and things as shall come to my knowledge as a member
of the Board of Disciplinary Appeals arising from
or in connection with each Disciplinary Action and
Disciplinary Proceeding unless permitted to disclose
the same in accordance with the Rules of Disciplinary
Procedure or unless ordered to do so in the course
of a judicial proceeding or a proceeding before
the Board of Disciplinary Appeals. I further solemnly
swear (or affirm) that I have neither directly nor
indirectly paid, offered, or promised to pay, contributed
any money or valuable thing, or promised any public
or private office to secure my appointment. So help
me God.”
7.05. Quorum
Six members constitute a quorum of the Board of
Disciplinary Appeals, except that a panel of three
members may hear appeals and such other matters
as may be specifically delegated to it by the Chair.
The Board of Disciplinary Appeals and each of its
panels may act only with the concurrence of a majority
of those members present and voting.
7.06. Compensation and Expenses
Members of the Board of Disciplinary Appeals are
entitled to reasonable compensation for their services
and reimbursement for travel and other expenses
incident to the performance of their duties.
7.07. Recusal and Disqualification of Members
Board of Disciplinary Appeals members shall refrain
from taking part in any matter before the Board
of Disciplinary Appeals in which recusal or disqualification
would be required of a judge similarly situated.
7.08. Powers and Duties
The Board of Disciplinary Appeals shall exercise
the following powers and duties:
A. Propose rules of procedure and administration
for its own operation to the Supreme Court of Texas
for promulgation.
B. Review the operation of the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals and periodically report to the Supreme Court
and to the Board.
C. Affirm or reverse without remand a determination
by the Chief Disciplinary Counsel that a statement
constitutes either: (i) an Inquiry as opposed to
a Complaint; or (ii) a Complaint as opposed to an
Inquiry.
D. Hear and determine appeals by the Complainant,
the Respondent, or the Chief Disciplinary Counsel
on the record from the decision of an evidentiary
panel of a Committee concerning the imposition or
failure to impose Sanctions. The appellate determination
must be made in writing and signed by the chair
or vice-chair of the Board of Disciplinary Appeals,
or other person presiding.
E. Transfer any pending Disciplinary Proceeding
from one Committee to another within the same District
if the one Committee fails or refuses to hear the
Disciplinary Proceeding.
F. Transfer matters from one Committee to another,
whether or not within the same District, when the
requirements of fairness to the Complainant or the
Respondent require.
G. Hear and determine actions for compulsory discipline
under Part VIII.
H. Hear and determine actions for reciprocal discipline
under Part IX.
I. Hear and determine actions for disability suspension
under Part XII.
J. Exercise all other powers and duties provide
in these rules.
7.09. Meetings
The Board of Disciplinary Appeals shall meet en
banc at least once each year at the call of its
chair. Its members may meet more often en banc at
the call of the chair or upon the written request
to the chair of at least three of the members of
the Board of Disciplinary Appeals.
7.10. Conference Calls
The Board of Disciplinary Appeals may, at the instance
of the chair, conduct its business by conference
telephone calls. Any action taken in a telephone
conference must be reduced to writing and signed
by each participant certifying the accuracy of the
written record of action taken.
7.11. Judicial Review
An appeal from a determination of the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals shall be to the Supreme Court. Within fourteen
days after receipt of notice of a final determination
by the Board of Disciplinary Appeals, the party
appealing must file a notice of appeal directly
with the Clerk of the Supreme Court. The record
must be filed within sixty days after the Board
of Disciplinary Appeals’ determination. The
appealing party’s brief is due thirty days
after the record is filed, and the responding party’s
brief must be filed within twenty-five days thereafter.
Except as herein expressly provided, the appeal
must be made pursuant to the then applicable Texas
Rules of Appellate Procedure. Oral argument may
be granted on motion. The case shall be reviewed
under the substantial evidence rule. The Court may
affirm a decision on the Board of Disciplinary Appeals
by order without written opinion. Determinations
by the Board of Disciplinary Appeals that a statement
constitutes either an inquiry or a complaint or
transferring cases are conclusive, and may not be
appealed to the Supreme Court.
7.12. Open Meetings and Open Records
The Board of Disciplinary Appeals is not a “governmental
body” as that term is defined in Section 551.001
or Section 552.003 of V.T.C.A., Government Code,
and is not subject to either the provisions of the
Open Meetings Act1 or the Open Records Act.2
PART VIII. COMPULSORY DISCIPLINE
8.01. Generally
When an attorney licensed to practice law in Texas
has been convicted of an Intentional Crime or has
been placed on probation for an Intentional Crime
with or without an adjudication of guilt, the Chief
Disciplinary Counsel shall initiate a Disciplinary
Action seeking compulsory discipline pursuant to
this part. The completion or termination of any
term of incarceration, probation, parole, or any
similar court ordered supervised period does not
bar action under Part VIII of these rules as hereinafter
provided. Proceedings under this part are not exclusive
in that an attorney may be disciplined as a result
of the underlying facts as well as being disciplined
upon the conviction or probation through deferred
adjudication.
8.02. Conclusive Evidence
In any Disciplinary Action brought under this part,
the record of conviction or order of deferred adjudication
is conclusive evidence of the attorney’s guilt.
8.03. Commencement of Suit
A Disciplinary Action under this part must be initiated
by the filing of a petition with the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals. The petition must allege the adjudication
of guilt (or probation without an adjudication of
guilt) of an Intentional Crime; allege that the
Respondent is the same person as the party adjudicated
guilty or who received probation with or without
an adjudication of guilt for such Intentional Crime;
and seek the appropriate discipline.
8.04. Procedure
The Board of Disciplinary Appeals shall hear and
determine all questions of law and fact. When an
attorney has been convicted of an Intentional Crime
or has been placed on probation for an Intentional
Crime without an adjudication of guilt, he or she
shall be suspended as an attorney licensed to practice
law in Texas during the appeal of the conviction
or the order of deferred adjudication. Upon introduction
into evidence of a certified copy of the judgment
of conviction or order of deferred adjudication
and a certificate of the Clerk of the Supreme Court
that the attorney is licensed to practice law in
Texas, the Board of Disciplinary Appeals shall immediately
determine whether the attorney has been convicted
of an Intentional Crime or granted probation without
an adjudication of guilt for an Intentional Crime.
Uncontroverted affidavits that the attorney is the
same person as the person convicted or granted probation
without an adjudication of guilt are competent and
sufficient evidence of those facts. Nothing in these
rules prohibits proof of the necessary elements
in such Disciplinary Action by competent evidence
in any other manner permitted by law. The Board
of Disciplinary Appeals shall sit, hear, and determine
whether the attorney should be disciplined and enter
judgment accordingly within forty-five days of the
answer day; however, any failure to do so within
the time limit will not affect its jurisdiction
to act. Any suspension ordered during the appeal
of a criminal conviction or probation without an
adjudication of guilt is interlocutory and immediately
terminates if the conviction or probation is set
aside or reversed.
8.05. Disbarment
When an attorney has been convicted of an Intentional
Crime, and that conviction has become final, or
the attorney has accepted probation with or without
an adjudication of guilt for an Intentional Crime,
the attorney shall be disbarred unless the Board
of Disciplinary Appeals, under Section 8.06, suspends
his or her license to practice law. If the attorney’s
license to practice law has been suspended during
the appeal of the criminal conviction, the Chief
Disciplinary Counsel shall file a motion for final
judgment of disbarment with the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals. If the motion is supported by affidavits
or certified copies of court documents showing that
the conviction has become final, the motion shall
be granted without hearing, unless within ten days
following the service of the motion pursuant to
Rule 21a, Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, upon the
attorney so convicted or his or her attorney of
record, the attorney so convicted files a verified
denial contesting the finality of the judgment,
in which event the Board of Disciplinary Appeals
will immediately conduct a hearing to determine
the issue. If no Disciplinary Action is pending
at the time the conviction becomes final, disbarment
shall be initiated by filing a Disciplinary Action.
8.06. Suspension
If an attorney’s sentence upon conviction
of an Serious Crime is fully probated, or if an
attorney receives probation through deferred adjudication
in connection with a Serious Crime, the attorney’s
license to practice law shall be suspended during
the term of probation. If an attorney is suspended
during the term of probation, the suspension shall
be conditioned upon the attorney’s satisfactorily
completing the terms of probation. If probation
is revoked, the attorney shall be disbarred. An
early termination of probation does not result in
reinstatement until the entire probationary period,
as originally assessed, has expired.
8.07. Early Termination
An early termination of criminal probation shall
have no effect on any judgment entered pursuant
to Part VIII.
8.08. No Supersedeas
In compulsory discipline cases, either party shall
have the right to appeal to the Supreme Court of
Texas but no Respondent suspended or disbarred by
the Board of Disciplinary Appeals shall be entitled
to practice law in any form while the appeal is
pending and shall have no right to supersede the
judgment by bond or otherwise.
PART IX. RECIPROCAL DISCIPLINE
9.01. Orders From Other Jurisdictions
Upon receipt of information indicating that an attorney
licensed to practice law in Texas has been disciplined
in another jurisdiction, the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel shall diligently seek to obtain a certified
copy of the order or judgment of discipline from
the other jurisdiction, and file it with the Board
of Disciplinary Appeals along with a petition requesting
that the attorney be disciplined in Texas. A certified
copy of the order or judgment is prima facie evidence
of the matters contained therein, and a final adjudication
in another jurisdiction that an attorney licensed
to practice law in Texas has committed Professional
Misconduct is conclusive for the purposes of a Disciplinary
Action in this state, subject to the defenses set
forth in Section 9.04 below.
9.02. Notice to the Respondent
Upon the filing of the petition, the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals shall issue a notice to the attorney, containing
a copy of the petition, a copy of the order or judgment
from the other jurisdiction, and an order directing
the attorney to show cause within thirty days from
the date of the mailing of the notice why the imposition
of the identical discipline in this state would
be unwarranted.
9.03. Discipline to be Imposed
If the attorney fails to file his or her answer
with the Board of Disciplinary Appeals within the
thirty-day period provided by Section 9.02, the
Board of Disciplinary Appeals shall enter a judgment
imposing discipline identical, to the extent practicable,
with that imposed in the other jurisdiction. If
the attorney files an answer, the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals shall proceed to determine the case upon
the pleadings, the evidence, and the briefs, if
any.
9.04. Defenses
If the Respondent files an answer, he or she shall
allege, and thereafter be required to prove, by
clear and convincing evidence, to the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals one or more of the following defenses to
avoid the imposition of discipline identical, to
the extent practicable, with that directed by the
judgment of the other jurisdiction:
A. That the procedure followed in the other jurisdiction
on the disciplinary matter was so lacking in notice
or opportunity to be heard as to constitute a deprivation
of due process.
B. That there was such an infirmity of proof establishing
the misconduct in the other jurisdiction as to give
rise to the clear conviction that the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals, consistent with its duty, should not accept
as final the conclusion on the evidence reached
in the other jurisdiction.
C. That the imposition by the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals of discipline identical, to the extent practicable,
with that imposed by the other jurisdiction would
result in grave injustice.
D. That the misconduct established in the other
jurisdiction warrants substantially different discipline
in this state.
E. That the misconduct for which the attorney was
disciplined in the other jurisdiction does not constitute
Professional Misconduct in this state.
If the Board of Disciplinary Appeals determines
that one or more of the foregoing defenses have
been established, it shall enter such orders as
it deems necessary and appropriate.
PART X. RESIGNATION IN LIEU OF DISCIPLINARY
ACTION
10.01. Disciplinary Resignation
Any person licensed to practice law in the State
of Texas shall be permitted to file a motion for
resignation in lieu of Disciplinary Action, in a
form promulgated by the Commission, in the Supreme
Court of Texas, attaching thereto his or her Texas
law license and permanent State Bar membership card.
10.02. Response of Chief Disciplinary Counsel
The Chief Disciplinary Counsel shall, within twenty
days after service upon him or her of a motion for
resignation in lieu of Disciplinary Action, file
a response on behalf of the State Bar (acting through
the Commission) stating whether the acceptance of
the resignation is in the best interest of the public
and the profession and setting forth a detailed
statement of the Professional Misconduct with which
the movant is charged. The movant may, within ten
days after service of such response, withdraw the
motion. If a motion to withdraw is not timely filed,
the detailed statement of Professional Misconduct
shall be deemed to have been conclusively established
for all purposes.
10.03. Effect of Filing
The filing of a motion for resignation in lieu of
Disciplinary Action does not, without the consent
of Chief Disciplinary Counsel, serve to delay or
abate any then pending Disciplinary Action or disciplinary
investigation.
10.04. Acceptance of Resignation and Notification
Any motion to resign in lieu of Disciplinary Action
under this part must be filed in the Supreme Court
and is ineffective until and unless accepted by
written order of the Supreme Court. The movant,
the chair of the movant’s Committee, the Commission,
and the Complainant, if any, shall be notified by
the Chief Disciplinary Counsel of the Court’s
disposition of such motion.
10.05. Effect of Resignation
Any resignation under this part shall be treated
as a disbarment for all purposes, including client
notification, discontinuation of practice, and reinstatement.
PART XI. REINSTATEMENT AFTER DISBARMENT
OR RESIGNATION
11.01. Eligibility and Venue
A disbarred person or a person who has resigned
in lieu of Disciplinary Action may, at any time
after the expiration of five years from the date
of final judgment of disbarment or the date of Supreme
Court order accepting resignation in lieu of Disciplinary
Action, petition the district court of the county
of his or her residence for reinstatement; provided,
however, that no person who has been disbarred or
resigned in lieu of discipline by reason of conviction
of or having been placed on probation without an
adjudication of guilt for an Intentional Crime or
a Serious Crime, is eligible to apply for reinstatement
until five years following the date of completion
of sentence, including any period of probation and/or
parole. If, at the time the petition for reinstatement
is filed, the disbarred person or person who has
resigned in lieu of Disciplinary Action is a nonresident
of the State of Texas, then the petition shall be
filed in Travis County, Texas.
11.02. Petition for Reinstatement
A petition for reinstatement shall be verified and
shall set forth all the following information:
A. The name, age, and residential address of the
petitioner.
B. The offenses, misconduct, or convictions upon
which the disbarment or resignation was based.
C. The name of the body or entity where the Disciplinary
Action was adjudicated and the identity of the Committee
before whom the Just Cause hearing was held.
D. A statement that the petitioner has made restitution
to all persons, if any, naming them and their current
addresses, who may have suffered financial loss
by reason of the offenses, misconduct, or Serious
Crimes for which the petitioner was disbarred or
resigned, and that the petitioner has paid all costs
and fines assessed in connection with the Disciplinary
Action that resulted in his or her disbarment.
E. A statement that at the time of the filing of
the petition the petitioner is of good moral character,
possesses the mental and emotional fitness to practice
law, and during the five years immediately preceding
the filing of the petition, has been living a life
of exemplary conduct.
F. A statement that the petitioner has recently
read and understands the Texas Disciplinary Rules
of Professional Conduct; that he or she has recently
read and understands the Texas Lawyers Creed—A
Mandate For Professionalism; that he or she has
a current knowledge of the law; and that the public
and profession will be served by the petitioner’s
reinstatement.
G. A listing of the petitioner’s occupations
from the date of disbarment or resignation, including
the names and current addresses of all partners,
associates, and employers, if any, and the dates
and duration of all such relationships and employment.
H. A statement listing all residences maintained
from the date of disbarment or resignation, and
the current names and addresses of all landlords.
I. A statement of the dates, cause numbers, courts,
and the general nature of all civil actions in which
the petitioner was a party or in which he or she
claimed an interest, and that were pending at any
time from the date of disbarment or resignation.
J. A statement of the dates, cause numbers, courts,
the general nature and disposition of all matters
pending at any time from the date of disbarment
or resignation and involving the prosecution of
the petitioner for any crime, felony, or misdemeanor,
together with the names and current addresses of
all complaining persons in each such matter.
K. A statement whether any application for a license
requiring proof of good moral character for its
procurement was filed at any time after the disbarment
or resignation and, for each application, the name
and address of the licensing authority and the disposition
of the application.
L. A statement explaining any proceeding or Inquiry
after the date of disbarment or resignation concerning
the petitioner’s standing as a member of any
profession or organization or holder of any license
or office that involved censure, removal, suspension
of license, revocation of any license, or discipline
of the petitioner and the disposition thereof, and
the name and address of each authority in possession
of the records.
M. A statement whether any allegations or charges,
formal or informal, of fraud were made or claimed
against the petitioner at any time after the disbarment
or resignation and the names and current addresses
of the persons or entities making such allegations
or charges.
The petitioner has a duty to amend and keep current
all information in the petition until the petition
has been heard and determined by the trial court.
11.03. Burden of Proof
The petitioner has the burden of establishing by
a preponderance of the evidence that the best interests
of the public and the profession, as well as the
ends of justice, would be served by his or her reinstatement.
The court shall deny the petition for reinstatement
if it contains any false statement of a material
fact or if the petitioner fails to meet the burden
of proof.
11.04. Notice and Procedure
The petitioner shall serve notice of a petition
for reinstatement by U.S. certified mail, return
receipt requested, on the Chief Disciplinary Counsel
and shall publish the notice as a paid classified
announcement in the Texas Bar Journal. After the
filing of the petition and service, the Texas Rules
of Civil Procedure shall apply except when in conflict
with these rules. All questions of fact and law
shall be determined by the trial court without the
aid of a jury.
11.05. Relevant Factors to be Considered
In determining the petitioner’s fitness for
reinstatement, in addition to any other relevant
matters, the trial court may consider:
A. Evidence concerning the nature and degree of
Professional Misconduct for which the petitioner
was disbarred or resigned and the circumstances
attending the offenses.
B. The petitioner’s understanding of the serious
nature of the acts for which he or she was disbarred
or resigned.
C. The petitioner’s conduct during the Disciplinary
Action.
D. The profit to the petitioner and the hardship
to others.
E. The petitioner’s attitude toward the administration
of justice and the practice of law.
F. The petitioner’s good works and other accomplishments.
G. Any other evidence relevant to the issues of
the petitioner’s fitness to practice law and
the likelihood that the petitioner will not engage
in further misconduct.
11.06. Judgment and Conditions
If the court is satisfied after hearing all the
evidence, both in support and in opposition to the
petition, that the material allegations of the petition
are true and that the best interests of the public
and the profession, as well as the ends of justice,
will be served, the court may render judgment authorizing
the petitioner to be reinstated upon his or her
compliance within eighteen months from the date
of the judgment with Rule II of the Rules Governing
Admission to the Bar of Texas in effect as of the
date upon which judgment authorizing reinstatement
is entered. The judgment shall direct the Board
of Law Examiners to admit the petitioner to a regularly
scheduled bar examination in accordance with that
board’s rules and procedures relating to the
examination of persons who have not previously been
licensed as lawyers in Texas or in any other state.
No judgment of reinstatement may be rendered by
default. If after hearing all the evidence the court
determines that the petitioner is not eligible for
reinstatement, the court may, in its discretion,
either enter a judgment denying the petition or
direct that the petition be held in abeyance for
a reasonable period of time until the petitioner
provides additional proof that he or she has satisfied
the requirements of these rules. The court’s
judgment may include such other orders as protecting
the public and the petitioner’s potential
clients may require.
11.07. Appeal and Readmission
When a judgment has been signed in any proceeding
under this part, the petitioner and the Commission
shall each have a right of appeal. If the petition
is granted and an appeal is perfected, the trial
court’s judgment shall be stayed pending resolution
of the appeal. After the petitioner has complied
with the terms of the judgment of reinstatement
and with this part, he or she shall furnish the
Commission with a certified copy of the judgment
and evidence of compliance and shall pay all membership
fees, license fees and assessments then owed and
the costs of the reinstatement proceeding. Upon
receipt of a certified copy of the judgment, evidence
of compliance and proof of payment of all membership
fees, license fees and assessments then owed, the
Commission shall direct the Chief Disciplinary Counsel
to issue a declaration of the petitioner’s
eligibility for licensure to the Clerk of the Supreme
Court. Upon receipt of such declaration, the Clerk
of the Supreme Court shall enter the name of the
petitioner on the membership rolls of the Supreme
Court and shall issue a new Bar card and law license
in the name of the petitioner reflecting as the
date of licensure the date of the declaration of
eligibility. Once the petitioner has taken the attorney’s
oath, the new Bar card and law license shall be
delivered by the Clerk of the Supreme Court to the
petitioner.
11.08. Repetitioning
If a petition for reinstatement is denied after
a hearing on the merits, the petitioner is not eligible
to file another petition until after the expiration
of three years from the date of final judgment denying
the last preceding petition.
PART XII. DISABILITY SUSPENSION
12.01. Grounds for Suspension
Any person licensed to practice law in the State
of Texas shall be suspended for an indefinite period
upon a finding that the attorney is suffering from
a Disability.
12.02. Procedure
Should the investigatory panel of a Committee find
that an attorney is suffering from a Disability,
the panel shall certify that finding and forward
the entire record immediately to the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals. Upon receipt of the record, the Board of
Disciplinary Appeals shall forward it to a District
Disability Committee to be composed of one attorney;
one doctor of medicine or mental health care provider
holding a doctorate degree, trained in the area
of Disability; and one public member who does not
have any interest, directly or indirectly, in the
practice of the law other than as a consumer. The
members of the District Disability Committee shall
be appointed ad hoc by the chair of the Board of
Disciplinary Appeals. The Board of Disciplinary
Appeals may appoint any attorney to represent the
interests of the disabled attorney.
12.03. District Disability Committee
The same rules regarding immunity, expenses, and
confidentiality as apply to members of a Committee
shall apply to the members appointed to a District
Disability Committee. The District Disability Committee
shall proceed in a de novo proceeding to receive
evidence and determine whether the attorney is suffering
from a Disability. The Respondent/attorney shall
be given reasonable notice of the preliminary finding
of Disability and the basis for it and shall be
afforded an opportunity to appear before, and present
evidence to, the District Disability Committee.
If there is no finding of Disability by the District
Disability Committee, the entire record and the
finding of the District Disability Committee will
be returned to the Committee and the matter shall
continue in the disciplinary process from the point
where it was referred to the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals for the determination of Disability. If,
however, there is a finding of Disability, the District
Disability Committee shall certify the finding to
the Board of Disciplinary Appeals.
12.04. Board of Disciplinary Appeals’ Responsibilities
Upon receiving a finding of Disability from the
District Disability Committee, the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals shall immediately enter its order suspending
the attorney indefinitely. The record of all proceedings
on disability must be sealed and must remain confidential,
except as to the Respondent; only the order of indefinite
suspension is to be made public.
12.05. Effect on Limitations
Any statute of limitations applying to a disciplinary
matter is tolled during the period of any Disability
suspension.
12.06. Reinstatement After Disability Suspension
An attorney who has been indefinitely suspended
under this part may have the suspension terminated
by filing a verified petition with the Board of
Disciplinary Appeals or a district court. Venue
of a district court action is:
A. In the county, immediately prior to suspension,
of Respondent’s principal place of practice.
B. If the Respondent did not maintain a place of
practice immediately before suspension within the
State of Texas, in the county of Respondent’s
residence.
C. If neither A. nor B. applies, then in Travis
County, Texas.
The petition must set out the attorney’s name,
address, the date, and the docket number of the
suspension, a detailed description of his or her
activities since the suspension, including employment,
the details of any hospitalization or medical treatment,
and any other matters the attorney believes entitles
him or her to termination of the suspension. A copy
of the petition shall be served by U.S. certified
mail, return receipt requested, upon the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel and the matter shall promptly thereafter
be set for hearing. The petition must have the following
documents attached: a certified copy of any court
order pertaining to the petitioner’s competence;
an affidavit from a mental health care provider
as to the petitioner’s current condition;
and a report from a physician as to the petitioner’s
current condition if the suspension was based in
whole or in part on the abuse or use of alcohol
or other drugs. Such attachments shall not constitute
evidence, per se, but the attachment of the same
is a requirement of pleading. In an action for reinstatement
under this part, either the Respondent or the Commission
shall have the right to a jury trial upon timely
payment of the required fee.
12.07. Burden of Proof
The petitioner has the burden to come forward and
prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that
the reasons for suspension no longer exist and that
termination of the suspension would be without danger
to the public and the profession. The Board of Disciplinary
Appeals or the district court, as the case may be,
may order the petitioner to be examined by one or
more health care providers trained in the area for
which the attorney was suspended.
12.08. Time for Filing Subsequent Petitions
A first petition for termination of suspension may
be filed at any time after the petitioner’s
license has been suspended under this part. If the
first petition is denied after a hearing, subsequent
petitions may not be filed until the expiration
of one year from the date of the denial of the last
preceding petition.
12.09. Judgment
If the attorney meets the burden of proof, the Board
of Disciplinary Appeals or the district court shall
order a termination of the period of suspension,
provided that whenever an attorney has been suspended
for a period of two or more consecutive years, he
or she may be required by the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals or the district court, as the case may be,
to obtain a passing grade on the multistate Professional
Responsibility portion of the State Bar examination
administered by the Board of Law Examiners, or take
a prescribed course of study through a law school
or through continuing legal education courses, or
do both.
12.10 Disability Probation
The Board of Disciplinary Appeals or the district
court, as the case may be, may order that an attorney
be placed on probation if the attorney has demonstrated
each of the following:
A. The ability to perform legal services and that
the attorney’s continued practice of law will
not cause the courts or profession to fall into
disrepair.
B. The unlikelihood of any harm to the public during
the period of rehabilitation and the adequate supervision
of necessary conditions of probation.
C. A Disability that can be successfully arrested
and treated while the attorney is engaged in the
practice of law.
Probation shall be ordered for a specified period
of time or until further order of the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals or the district court, as the case may be,
whenever a suspension is probated in whole or in
part.
12.11. Conditions
The order placing an attorney on Disability probation
must state the conditions of probation. The conditions
must take into consideration the nature and circumstances
of the Professional Misconduct and the history,
character, and condition of the attorney. Any or
all of the following conditions, and such others
as the Board of Disciplinary Appeals or the district
court deems appropriate, may be imposed:
A. Periodic reports to the Chief Disciplinary Counsel.
B. Supervision over client trust accounts as the
Board of Disciplinary Appeals or the district court
may direct.
C. Satisfactory completion of a course of study.
D. Successful completion of the multistate Professional
Responsibility Examination.
E. Restitution.
F. Compliance with income tax laws and verification
of such to Chief Disciplinary Counsel.
G. Limitations on practice.
H. Psychological evaluation, counseling, and treatment.
I. The abstinence from alcohol or drugs.
J. Payment of costs (including Reasonable Attorneys’
Fees and all direct expenses) associated with the
proceedings.
K. Substance abuse evaluation, counseling, and treatment.
L. Participation in an Impaired Attorney Recovery
and Supervision Program if such a program has been
adopted by the Board of Directors of the State Bar
of Texas.
12.12. Administration
The Chief Disciplinary Counsel is responsible for
the supervision of attorneys placed on Disability
probation. Where appropriate, he or she may recommend
to the Board of Disciplinary Appeals or to the district
court, as the case may be, the modification of the
conditions and shall report any failure of the probationer
to comply with the conditions of probation. Upon
a showing of failure to comply with the conditions
of probation, the Board of Disciplinary Appeals
or the district court, as the case may be, may revoke
the probation or impose such other conditions deemed
necessary for the protection of the public and the
rehabilitation of the attorney.
12.13. Appeals
A final judgment of the Board of Disciplinary Appeals
denying a petition for reinstatement may be appealed
to the Supreme Court. If such an appeal is taken,
it must be filed with the Clerk of the Supreme Court
within fourteen days after the receipt by the appealing
party of the determination of the Board of Disciplinary
Appeals. Except as herein expressly provided, an
appeal must be made pursuant to the then applicable
Texas Rules of Appellate Procedure. Oral argument
may be granted on motion. The case shall be reviewed
under the substantial-evidence rule. The Court may
affirm a decision of the Board of Disciplinary Appeals
by order without written opinion. A final judgment
of a district court denying a petition for reinstatement
may be appealed as in civil cases generally.
PART XIII. CESSATION OF PRACTICE
13.01. Notice of Attorney’s Cessation of
Practice
When an attorney licensed to practice law in Texas
dies, resigns, becomes inactive, is disbarred, or
is suspended, leaving an active client matter for
which no other attorney licensed to practice in
Texas, with the consent of the client, has agreed
to assume responsibility, written notice of such
cessation of practice (together with information
identifying the matter) shall be mailed to all clients,
former clients, opposing counsel, courts, agencies
with which the attorney has matters pending, malpractice
insurers, and any other person or entity having
reason to be informed of the cessation of practice.
If the attorney dies, or has a mental or emotional
Disability, the notice shall be given by the personal
representative of the attorney or by any person
having lawful custody of the files and records of
the attorney. In all other cases, notice shall be
given by the attorney, a person authorized by the
attorney, a person having lawful custody of the
files of the attorney, or by Chief Disciplinary
Counsel.
13.02. Assumption of Jurisdiction
A client of the attorney, Chief Disciplinary Counsel,
or any other interested person may petition a district
court in the county of the attorney’s residence
to assume jurisdiction over the attorney’s
law practice. The petition must be verified and
must state the facts necessary to show cause to
believe that notice of cessation is required under
this part. It must state the following:
A. That an attorney licensed to practice law in
Texas has died, disappeared, resigned, become inactive,
been disbarred or suspended, or become physically,
mentally or emotionally disabled and cannot provide
legal services necessary to protect the legal interests
of clients.
B. That cause exists to believe that court supervision
is necessary because the attorney has left client
matters for which no other attorney licensed to
practice law in Texas has, with the consent of the
client, agreed to assume responsibility.
C. That there is cause to believe that the interests
of one or more clients of the attorney or one or
more interested persons or entities will be prejudiced
if these proceedings are not maintained.
13.03. Hearing and Order on Application to Assume
Jurisdiction
The court shall set the petition for hearing and
issue an order to show cause, directing the attorney
or his or her personal representative, or if none
exists, the person having custody of the attorney’s
files, to show cause why the court should not assume
jurisdiction of the attorney’s law practice.
If the court finds that one or more of the events
stated in Section 13.02 has occurred and that the
supervision of the court is required, the court
shall assume jurisdiction and appoint one or more
attorneys licensed to practice law in Texas to do
one or more of the following as specified in the
court’s written order:
A. Examine the client matters, including files and
records of the attorney’s practice, and obtain
information about any matters that may require attention.
B. Notify persons and entities that appear to be
clients of the attorney of the assumption of the
law practice, and suggest that they obtain other
legal counsel.
C. Apply for extension of time before any court
or any administrative body pending the client’s
employment of other legal counsel.
D. With the prior consent of the client, file such
motions and pleadings on behalf of the client as
are required to prevent prejudice to the client’s
rights.
E. Give appropriate notice to persons or entities
that may be affected other than the client.
F. Arrange for surrender or delivery to the client
of the client’s papers, files, or other property.
The custodian shall observe the attorney-client
relationship and privilege as if the custodians
were the attorney of the client and may make only
such disclosures as are necessary to carry out the
purposes of this part. Except for intentional misconduct
or gross negligence, no person acting under this
part may incur any liability by reason of the institution
or maintenance of a proceeding under this Part XIII.
No bond or other security is required.
PART XIV. INTERIM SUSPENSION
14.01. Irreparable Harm to Clients
Upon a finding by an investigatory panel that
an attorney poses a substantial threat of irreparable
harm to clients or prospective clients, the investigatory
panel shall authorize Chief Disciplinary Counsel
to seek the immediate interim suspension of the
attorney. The Chief Disciplinary Counsel shall file
a petition with a district court of proper venue
alleging immediate irreparable harm, and the district
court shall, if the petition alleges facts that
meet the evidentiary standard in Section 14.02,
set a hearing within ten days. If the Chief Disciplinary
Counsel, at the hearing, meets the evidentiary standard
and burden of proof as established in Section 14.02,
the court shall enter an order without requiring
bond, immediately suspending the attorney pending
the final disposition of the Disciplinary Proceedings
or the Disciplinary Action based on the conduct
causing the harm. The matter shall thereafter proceed
in the district court as in matters involving temporary
injunctions under the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure.
If a temporary injunction is entered, the court
may appoint a custodian under Part XIII. If, at
the conclusion of all Disciplinary Proceedings and
Disciplinary Actions, the Respondent is not found
to have committed Professional Misconduct, the immediate
interim suspension may not be deemed a “Sanction”
for purposes of insurance applications or any other
purpose.
14.02. Burden of Proof and Evidentiary Standard
The Chief Disciplinary Counsel has the burden to
prove the case for an interim suspension by a preponderance
of the evidence. If proved by a preponderance of
the evidence, any one of the following elements
establishes conclusively that the attorney poses
a substantial threat of irreparable harm to clients
or prospective clients:
A. Conduct by an attorney that includes all of the
elements of a Serious Crime as defined in these
rules.
B. Three or more acts of Professional Misconduct,
as defined in subsections (a)(2) (3) (4) (6) (7)
(8) or (10) of Rule 8.04 of the Texas Disciplinary
Rules of Professional Conduct, whether or not actual
harm or threatened harm is demonstrated.
C. Failure of a Respondent to furnish information
subpoenaed by a Committee, unless he or she, in
good faith, asserts a privilege or other legal grounds
for the failure to do so.
D. Any other conduct by an attorney that, if continued,
will probably cause harm to clients or prospective
clients.
PART XV. MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS
15.01. Subpoena Power
Chief Disciplinary Counsel or Respondent may compel
the attendance of witnesses, including the Respondent,
and the production of books, documents, papers,
banking records, and other things by subpoena. The
subpoena must notify the witness of the time, date,
and place of appearance and must contain a description
of the materials to be produced. Subpoenas must
be in writing and signed and issued by the chair
of the panel. The party seeking the subpoena shall
submit it in a proper form and is responsible for
securing service. Any contest between the Chief
Disciplinary Counsel and the Respondent about the
materiality of the testimony or production sought
by a subpoena shall be determined by the chair of
the panel, and is subject to review. Subpoenas must
be served on witnesses personally or in accordance
with Rule 21a, Texas Rules of Civil Procedure. Proof
of service shall be by certification of the server
or by the return receipt. The subpoena is enforceable
by the district court of the county in which the
attendance or production is required. Witnesses
shall be paid witness fees and mileage the same
as for a district court.
15.02. Enforcement of Subpoenas and Examination
Before a District Judge
If any witness, including the Respondent, fails
or refuses to appear or to produce the things named
in the subpoena, or refuses to be sworn or to affirm
or to testify, the witness may be compelled to appear
and produce tangible evidence and to testify at
a hearing before a district judge of the county
in which the subpoena was served. The application
for such a hearing is to be styled “In re:
Hearing Before The District ________ Disciplinary
Committee.” The court shall order a time,
date, and place for the hearing and shall notify
Chief Disciplinary Counsel, the Respondent, and
the witness. Unless the Respondent requests a public
hearing, the proceedings before the court shall
be closed and all records relating to the hearing
shall be sealed and made available only to Chief
Disciplinary Counsel, the Respondent, or the witness.
If the witness fails or refuses to appear, testify,
or produce such tangible evidence, he or she shall
be punished for civil contempt.
15.03. Enforcement of Judgments
The following judgments have the force of a final
judgment of a district court: consent judgments
entered into by the Respondent and an investigatory
panel, consent judgments entered into by the Respondent
and an evidentiary panel, final judgments of an
evidentiary panel, and judgments entered by the
Board of Disciplinary Appeals. To enforce a judgment,
the Chief Disciplinary Counsel may apply to a district
court in the county of the residence of the Respondent.
In enforcing the judgment, the court has available
to it all writs and processes, as well as the power
of contempt, to enforce the judgment as if the judgment
had been the courts own.
15.04. Effect of Related Litigation
The processing of an Inquiry, Complaint, Disciplinary
Proceeding, or Disciplinary Action is not, except
for good cause, to be delayed or abated because
of substantial similarity to the material allegations
in pending civil or criminal litigation.
15.05. Effect on Related Litigation
Neither the Complainant nor the Respondent is affected
by the doctrines of res judicata or estoppel by
judgment from any Disciplinary Action.
15.06. Effect of Delay or Settlement by Complainant
None of the following alone justifies the discontinuance
or abatement of any Inquiry or Complaint being processed
through the disciplinary system: (1) the unwillingness
or the neglect of a Complainant to sign a Complaint
or to prosecute a charge; (2) the settlement or
compromise of matters between the Complainant and
the Respondent; (3) restitution by the Respondent.
15.07. Effect of Time Limitations
The time periods provided in Sections 2.09, 2.10,
2.13, 2.16(B), 2.16(G), 2.19, 2.20, 3.04, 4.06(A),
7.11, 8.06, 9.02, 10.02 and 11.01 are mandatory.
All other time periods herein provided are directory
only and the failure to comply with them does not
result in the invalidation of an act or event by
reason of the noncompliance with those time limits.
15.08. Limitations, Rules and Exceptions
No attorney licensed to practice law in Texas may
be disciplined for Professional Misconduct occurring
more than four years before the time when the allegation
of Professional Misconduct is brought to the attention
of the Office of Chief Disciplinary Counsel, except
in cases in which disbarment or suspension is compulsory.
Limitations will not begin to run where fraud or
concealment is involved until such Professional
Misconduct is discovered or should have been discovered
in the exercise of reasonable diligence by the Complainant.
15.09. Residence
For purposes of these rules, a person licensed to
practice law in Texas is considered a resident of
the county in Texas of his or her principal residence.
A person licensed to practice law in Texas but not
residing in Texas is deemed to be a resident of
Travis County, Texas, for all purposes.
15.10. Privilege
All communications, written and oral, and all other
materials and statements to or from the Commission,
Chief Disciplinary Counsel, the Complainant, the
Respondent, and others directly involved in the
filing, screening, investigation, and disposition
of Inquiries and Complaints are absolutely privileged.
15.11. Immunity
Communications to the Chief Disciplinary Counsel
or grievance committee relating to attorney misconduct
or disability and testimony given at any disciplinary
proceeding shall be absolutely privileged and no
lawsuit predicated thereon may be instituted against
any complainant or witness. All members of the Commission,
the Chief Disciplinary Counsel and his or her staff
(including Special Assistant Disciplinary Counsel
appointed by the Commission and attorneys employed
on a contract basis by the Chief Disciplinary Counsel),
all members of Committees, all members of the Board
of Disciplinary Appeals, all members of the District
Disability Committees, and all officers and Directors
of the State Bar are immune from suit for any conduct
in the course of their official duties. The immunity
is absolute and unqualified and extends to all actions
at law or in equity.
15.12. Maintenance of Funds or Other Property Held
for Clients and Others
Every attorney licensed to practice law in Texas
who maintains, or is required to maintain, a separate
client trust account or accounts, designated as
such, into which funds of clients or other fiduciary
funds must be deposited, shall further maintain
and preserve for a period of five years after final
disposition of the underlying matter, the records
of such accounts, including checkbooks, canceled
checks, check stubs, check registers, bank statements,
vouchers, deposit slips, ledgers, journals, closing
statements, accountings, and other statements of
receipts and disbursements rendered to clients or
other parties with regard to client trust funds
or other similar records clearly reflecting the
date, amount, source, and explanation for all receipts,
withdrawals, deliveries, and disbursements of the
funds or other property of a client.
15.13. Restrictions on Imposition of Certain Sanctions
A. Public reprimands shall not be utilized if:
(1) A public reprimand has been imposed upon the
Respondent within the preceding five (5) year period
for a violation of the same disciplinary rule; or
(2) The Respondent has previously received two (2)
or more public reprimands whether or not for violation
of the same disciplinary rule within the preceding
five (5) year period.
B. Fully probated suspensions shall not be utilized
if:
(1) A public reprimand or fully probated suspension
has been imposed upon the Respondent within the
preceding five (5) year period for a violation of
the same disciplinary rule; or
(2) The Respondent has previously received two (2)
or more fully probated suspension whether or not
for violations of the same disciplinary rule within
the preceding five (5) year period; or
(3) The Respondent has previously received two (2)
or more sanctions of public reprimand or greater
imposed for conflict of interest, theft, misapplication
of fiduciary property, or the failure to return,
after demand, a clearly unearned fee.
C. In the event that a fully probated suspension
is not available under this rule, any sanction imposed
shall be for no less than thirty (3) days of active
suspension.
|